Key takeaways
- Define a complete return by the inspection, the wipe, and the reconciliation, not the physical handback.
- Measure the days from the due date to the return and from the return to the wipe.
- Reconcile the loaner log against the asset register and the insurance list every quarter.
- Record border inspections and lost devices with the same discipline as an ordinary return.
Question and scope
This study asks how often executive loaner devices are returned on time, in usable condition, and with their data removed. The unit is one device issue tied to one traveler and one trip. The review follows the pool record, the issue terms, the custody log, the return inspection, and the reconciliation. It does not judge whether the trip justified a loaner.
Set the scope to one device pool and a fixed period, such as two consecutive quarters. Record the number of devices, the issue count, and the maximum loan term. If the pool changed during the period, separate the issues. A new device model can change the return behavior without changing the process.
Include a short trip, a long assignment, and an issue that crossed a border. Include at least one device that was reported lost. Record the category and the outcome. A sample of only returned devices will understate the problem.
Include a device issued to an assistant on the executive's behalf and one issued directly to the executive. The two handoffs produce different evidence. Record the receiver and the witness. The study should test the chain of custody, not only the final return.
What the sources establish
CISA's public guidance describes device and data protection practices that support a controlled loaner pool without prescribing an executive office log. NIST's Cybersecurity Framework describes identify, protect, detect, respond, and recover functions, which supports a record of custody and return. GAO's Green Book describes control activities and documentation, which supports reconciliation. The sources do not define a loaner term or a return inspection checklist.
The sources do not establish how long a device may be kept or who must sign for it. They also do not say whether a device that crossed a border can return to the pool. The study therefore measures the office's own rule and the record it produces. The report should keep that local scope visible.
The sources support separating the custody question from the data question. A device can be returned on time and still carry the traveler's data. The study should test both elements. A device that is physically present is not evidence that the return was controlled.
Definitions and measures
Define a complete loaner record as one with the asset tag, the issue date, the due date, the receiver, the build check, the accessories, the return inspection, the wipe, and the reconciliation. Keep the field list fixed across the sample. A record with no return inspection is counted as incomplete even when the device came back. The same list should apply to every issue in the period.
Measure the days from the due date to the return and from the return to the wipe. A device can be returned late and wiped promptly, or returned on time and left un wiped. Report both intervals. The measure shows whether the office controlled the data as well as the hardware.
Record the condition at issue and at return, including damage and missing accessories. A comparison is more useful than a single condition grade. Report the change. Keep that field beside the asset tag.
Record whether the device crossed a border where it was inspected or seized and whether the security owner was notified. A border event changes the risk even when the device returns. Report the event and the response. The study should test the notification, not only the outcome.
Sampling and collection
Sample issues from the loaner log, the travel calendar, and the asset register. Include an issue that was never logged and later found in the asset register. Record the source and the category. A log-only sample will miss the devices that left without an entry.
Collect the issue form, the build check, the accessories list, the return inspection, the wipe record, and the reconciliation. Mask personal data that is not needed. If the device was re-imaged, record the image and the date. A return without a wipe record is still an open data question.
Include a device that was returned by a courier rather than in person. A courier return has a different chain of custody and a different damage risk. Record the carrier and the receipt. The study should test the handoff, not only the destination.
Include a device that was replaced mid-trip after a failure. A replacement creates two custody chains that are easy to merge incorrectly. Record both asset tags and the swap date. The study should test whether the log kept them separate.
Verification pathway
Check the return inspection against the device itself or a dated photograph rather than the traveler's statement. A statement that the device is fine is not an inspection. Record the check and the date. The study should include at least one device with hidden damage.
Confirm that the device was wiped and removed from the executive's account before it was reissued. A reissue to a second traveler is the point where a data error becomes a disclosure. Record the wipe and the account removal. The study should test the reissue, not only the return.
Check the log against the asset register and the insurance list and record every difference. A device can be present in one list and absent from the other two. Record the three counts. The study should include a reconciliation done by someone who did not issue the device.
Confirm that a lost or seized device was reported to the security owner and that the response is documented. A report without a response leaves the exposure open. Record the report and the action. The study should test the response, not only the notification.
Analysis and reporting
Report the number of issues, the on-time return rate, the median days late, the wipe rate, and the reconciliation match rate. Break the results down by traveler and by trip type. Report the lost and seized devices separately. A single return rate can hide a data problem on devices that came back.
Inspect the gaps for patterns. A cluster of late returns may point to the maximum term, while a cluster of missing wipes may point to the return desk. Choose one change, such as a shorter default term or a wipe-before-reissue rule. Do not rank travelers by return rate when their trip lengths differ.
Report the days from the return to the wipe, not only the return date. A device can sit on a shelf with data for a month. Show the median and the longest case. The measure reflects the risk the office actually carried.
Limits and next action
The study cannot prove that every device left through the log or that a wipe removed every copy of the data. It also cannot capture a border inspection that was never reported. The report should state those limits and avoid treating the log as the asset register. Keep the pool record with the study so the next reviewer can check the same list.
Set a repeat study date and keep the field list stable. Assign the correction to the device owner and give the executive a one-page travel device card. The next quarter should test whether the same term or the same wipe step fails again. A useful result is a device that is returned, wiped, and reconciled before it is reissued.
Keep the study record with the asset register so a later review can compare the claim with the evidence. Set the next sample date and name the owner. A device routine that is not reviewed will lapse with the next pool change. The office should be able to show what improved.
Sources
- Secretaries and Administrative Assistants, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook.
- Executive Secretaries and Executive Administrative Assistants, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics.
- Executive Secretaries and Executive Administrative Assistants, O*NET OnLine.
- Business Formation Statistics, U.S. Census Bureau.
- Nonfarm Business Sector: Labor Productivity, Federal Reserve Economic Data.
- Productivity Statistics, OECD Data Explorer.
- World Development Indicators, World Bank DataBank.
- ILOSTAT Labour Statistics, International Labour Organization.
- 2024 Work Trend Index Annual Report, Microsoft and LinkedIn.
- The economic potential of generative AI, McKinsey Global Institute.
- Creating helpful, reliable, people first content, Google Search Central.
- Search Engine Optimization Starter Guide, Google Search Central.
- Dear Manager, You Are Holding Too Many Meetings, Harvard Business Review.
- CISA, Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency.
- NIST Cybersecurity Framework.
- GAO, Standards for Internal Control in the Federal Government (Green Book).
Related research
Apply the research
Use the finding to frame one question for your own team: which support work is currently invisible, and who should own the next step? A scoped consultation can turn that question into a practical role. Write the question down before the meeting. Name the person who owns the next step.
Turn the finding into a support scope.
Bring the workflow that feels hardest to see. We will help define the role, the evidence it should maintain, and the decisions that stay with leadership.
Talk through the role