Key takeaways
- Define completeness by a named owner, the notice date, the approval, the invoice match, and the access review.
- Reconcile the register to both the company card and the reimbursed personal card every quarter.
- Check that the notice date is calculated from the contract, not copied from the renewal date.
- Count seat and access differences as findings, not only price variances.
Question and scope
This audit asks whether an executive office can show what subscriptions it pays for, who owns each one, when the notice date falls, who approved the renewal, and what access was removed when a user left. The unit is one subscription over one renewal cycle. The review follows the register, the renewal calendar, the approval, the invoice, and the access record. It does not judge whether the subscription was good value.
Set the scope to one office and a fixed period, such as four consecutive quarters, and list every subscription charge on the company card and the reimbursed personal card. If the office changed finance systems during the period, separate the charges by system. Record the count and the vendors. A sample drawn only from the largest invoices will miss the small renewals that accumulate.
Include a subscription that lapsed, a subscription that renewed at a higher price, and at least one subscription with no named owner. A lapsed subscription tests whether the notice date was tracked. Record the category and the outcome. The sample should include an annual renewal and a monthly one.
What the sources establish
GAO's Green Book describes control activities, documentation, and segregation of duties as parts of internal control, which supports a register with an approver. NIST SP 800-53 describes account management and access removal as security controls, which supports a seat review after departure. BLS occupational data describes the purchasing role but not a subscription register. The sources do not define an executive office renewal record.
The sources do not set an approval threshold or a required notice period. They also do not say how a subscription on a personal card should be recorded. The audit therefore measures the office's own register and the charges it can reconcile. The report should keep that local scope visible.
The sources support separating the commercial decision from the access decision. A renewal can be properly approved and still leave a departed user with an active account. The audit should test both elements. A paid invoice is not evidence that the access was reviewed.
Definitions and measures
Define a complete subscription record as one with the vendor, the purpose, the owner, the amount, the billing frequency, the renewal date, the notice date, the contract term, the payment method, and the data category. Keep the field list fixed across the sample. A subscription without an owner is counted as incomplete. The same list should apply to the annual and monthly charges.
Measure the share of charges matched to a register entry, the share of renewals approved before the notice date, and the days from renewal to invoice reconciliation. A renewal approved after the charge is a decision made in hindsight. Report all three measures. They show whether the register is used before the money moves.
Record whether access was removed for each departed user and whether the seat count on the invoice matches the active users. A seat that is paid but unused is a cost and an access question. Report the difference separately. The audit should treat the seat count as part of the record.
Sampling and collection
Sample subscriptions from the card statements, the finance ledger, and the register itself. Include a charge that has no register entry and an entry that has no charge in the period. Record the source and the category. A register-only sample will miss the subscriptions that were never added.
Collect the register entry, the contract or terms, the approval, the invoice, the payment record, and the access list. Mask the card number and keep only the last four digits. If the subscription is on a personal card, record the reimbursement. The file should show the full cost to the company, not only the charge.
Include a subscription that changed owner during the period and one that was transferred to a team agreement. An ownership change is the most likely point for the renewal to be missed. Record the change and the confirmation. The sample should test the register when the people move.
Verification pathway
Match each invoice to the approved renewal and the contracted price, and record any variance in seats, term, or rate. A renewal that charges for more seats than approved is a common finding. Record the invoice, the approval, and the difference. The audit should test the charge, not only the entry.
Confirm that the notice date in the register was calculated from the contract rather than copied from the renewal date. A notice period that is wrong by a month can remove the option to cancel. Record the calculation and the source. The audit should test the date the office would actually rely on.
Confirm that access was removed for every departed user and that the vendor's user list matches the office's record. A vendor list that still shows a former employee is an access finding. Record the list and the removal date. The audit should include a user who left during the period.
Analysis and reporting
Report the number of subscriptions, the share matched to the register, the share approved before the notice date, and the total unreconciled spend. Break the results down by category and by owner. Report the subscriptions with no owner separately. A single match rate can hide a set of small charges that no one reviews.
Inspect the gaps for patterns. A cluster of unlisted charges may point to the reimbursement route, while a cluster of late approvals may point to the renewal calendar. Choose one change, such as a monthly card reconciliation or a notice-date field. Do not rank owners by match rate when their subscription mix differs.
Report the renewals that were cancelled or moved to a team agreement and the saving recorded for each. A register that never produces a cancellation is a list rather than a control. Show the count and the measured saving. The measure reflects the use of the register rather than its size.
Limits and next action
The audit cannot prove that a subscription was necessary or that the price was the best available. It also cannot capture a charge that was paid outside the company and never reimbursed. The report should state those limits and avoid treating the register as a complete spend record. Keep the statements and the approvals with the study so the next reviewer can check the same record.
Set a repeat audit date and keep the field list stable. Assign the correction to the office manager and give the budget owner a one-page renewal calendar. The next quarter should test whether the same unlisted charge or the same late approval fails again. A useful result is a renewal that is decided before the notice date.
Keep the audit record with the subscription files so a later review can compare the claim with the evidence. Set the next sample date and name the owner. A renewal routine that is not reviewed will lapse with the next finance change. The office should be able to show what improved.
Sources
- Secretaries and Administrative Assistants, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook.
- Executive Secretaries and Executive Administrative Assistants, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics.
- Executive Secretaries and Executive Administrative Assistants, O*NET OnLine.
- Business Formation Statistics, U.S. Census Bureau.
- Nonfarm Business Sector: Labor Productivity, Federal Reserve Economic Data.
- Productivity Statistics, OECD Data Explorer.
- World Development Indicators, World Bank DataBank.
- ILOSTAT Labour Statistics, International Labour Organization.
- 2024 Work Trend Index Annual Report, Microsoft and LinkedIn.
- The economic potential of generative AI, McKinsey Global Institute.
- Creating helpful, reliable, people first content, Google Search Central.
- Search Engine Optimization Starter Guide, Google Search Central.
- Dear Manager, You Are Holding Too Many Meetings, Harvard Business Review.
- GAO, Standards for Internal Control in the Federal Government (Green Book).
- NIST, Security and Privacy Controls for Information Systems and Organizations (SP 800-53).
- BLS, Purchasing Managers, Buyers, and Purchasing Agents.
Related research
Apply the research
Use the finding to frame one question for your own team: which support work is currently invisible, and who should own the next step? A scoped consultation can turn that question into a practical role. Write the question down before the meeting. Name the person who owns the next step.
Turn the finding into a support scope.
Bring the workflow that feels hardest to see. We will help define the role, the evidence it should maintain, and the decisions that stay with leadership.
Talk through the role