Commitment tracking

Auditing Charitable Commitment Records in an Executive Office

An audit protocol for charitable and community commitments, covering the request, the capacity, the approval, the payment, and the acknowledgment.

5 min readHireExecutiveTeam research

Key takeaway Separate personal, corporate, and board-role commitments, and test each one against the approval, payer, and acknowledgment it actually has.

Auditing Charitable Commitment Records in an Executive Office research illustration
Table of contents
  1. Key takeaways
  2. Question and scope
  3. What the sources establish
  4. Definitions and measures
  5. Sampling and collection
  6. Verification pathway
  7. Analysis and reporting
  8. Limits and next action
  9. Sources
  10. Related research
  11. Apply the research

Key takeaways

  • Record the capacity and the payer for every commitment.
  • Check that the approver had authority for that capacity.
  • Date the organization's tax-status check and keep it with the file.
  • Report verbal and multi-year commitments separately.

Question and scope

This audit asks whether an executive office can show what the executive and the company committed to charitable and community organizations and who approved each commitment. The unit is one commitment tied to one organization and one capacity. The review follows the request, the approval, the payment, and the acknowledgment. It does not judge whether the cause was worthy.

Set the scope to one executive, one company, and one year. Record the foundation, the community program, and the personal giving process. If the executive's role changed during the year, separate the periods. A promotion can change who may approve a commitment.

Include pledges, one-time gifts, sponsorships, board seats, and in-kind support. Include at least one declined request and one multi-year pledge. Record the type and the capacity. A sample of only completed gifts will miss the commitments that create the most risk.

Include a commitment made at a public event. A verbal pledge made from a stage is still a commitment. Record the event and the witness. The audit should test whether the office captured it after the fact.

What the sources establish

IRS Publication 526 describes the records that support a charitable deduction, which supports an evidence-based review without prescribing an office register. The same sources do not set an approval level for a corporate pledge. The IRS Tax Exempt Organization Search supports checking an organization's status. GAO's Green Book supports separating an approval control from the evidence that it operated.

The sources do not establish a required approval level or a standard pledge letter. They also do not say which commitments must be disclosed. The audit therefore measures the office's own rule and the record it produces. The report should keep that local scope visible.

The sources support separating a personal gift from a corporate commitment. The two can share an organization and still need different approvals and records. The audit should record the capacity and the payer. A single total for both is not a useful control.

Definitions and measures

Define a commitment as a promise of money, time, or in-kind support, whether written or verbal. Define a complete record as one with the organization, the amount, the capacity, the approver, the payment schedule, and the acknowledgment. Keep the field list fixed. A verbal commitment with no written follow-up is counted as incomplete.

Measure the time from the request to the approval and from the approval to the first payment. A commitment approved after the event may still be valid. Report both intervals. The measure shows where the process slows.

Record whether the commitment was personal, corporate, or made in a board role, and whether the approver had authority for that capacity. Report the three capacities separately. Keep that field beside the amount in every list. A commitment approved by the wrong capacity is a governance finding, not a filing error.

Record the public recognition attached to each commitment and whether the executive approved it. A name on a program can disclose more than the gift. Report the recognition and the approval. The audit should treat visibility as part of the record.

Sampling and collection

Sample commitments from the check register, the foundation minutes, the executive's correspondence, and the organizations' published donor lists. Include a board seat and a sponsorship. Record the source and the type. A check-register sample alone will miss in-kind and verbal commitments.

Collect the request, the approval, the pledge letter, the payment record, and the acknowledgment. Mask personal details that are not needed. If the commitment was made verbally, record the event and the follow-up. A verbal pledge needs a written confirmation.

Include a commitment that was paid by a different entity than the one that approved it. A payer mismatch is a common control gap. Record the approver and the payer. The audit should test whether the two agree.

Verification pathway

Check the organization's tax status against the IRS Tax Exempt Organization Search and record the date. A status check that is not dated cannot be relied on later. Report the result. The audit should include at least one organization whose status changed.

Confirm that the approver had authority for the capacity and the amount. A personal commitment approved by a company officer is not a corporate commitment. Record the capacity and the limit. The audit should test the rule, not only the signature.

Match the payment record to the pledge schedule and the acknowledgment. A payment without an acknowledgment is harder to support and harder to explain. Record the three items. The audit should flag a partial or missing acknowledgment.

Check whether the public recognition matched what the executive approved. A logo or a name used beyond the approved scope is a disclosure issue. Record the approval and the published item. The audit should include the organization's website or program.

Analysis and reporting

Report the number of commitments, the record completeness rate, the approval rate, and the acknowledgment rate. Break the results down by capacity, type, and entity. Report the verbal and multi-year commitments separately. A single completeness rate can hide a governance gap.

Inspect the failures for patterns. A cluster of missing approvals may point to a delegated process, while a cluster of payer mismatches may point to an entity structure. Choose one change, such as a pledge form or an annual register review. Do not rank staff by completeness when their commitment mix differs.

Report the time from request to approval and from approval to payment. A commitment that is approved late can still be paid on time, while one approved early can drift. Show both intervals. The measure should reflect the control, not only the outcome.

Limits and next action

The audit cannot prove that every commitment was recorded or that the organization used the funds as promised. It also cannot capture a pledge made in a private conversation with no witness. The report should state those limits and avoid treating the register as the whole record. Keep the pledge file with the study so the next review can test the same fields.

Set a repeat audit date and keep the field list stable. Assign the correction to the executive office lead and give the finance team a short pledge checklist. The next year should test whether the same capacity or the same acknowledgment step fails again. A useful result is a register that can answer a board question.

Keep the audit record with the pledge file and the annual giving summary so a later review can compare the two. Set the next sample date and name the owner. A register that is not reviewed will drift as the executive's role changes. The office should be able to show what it fixed.

Sources

  1. Secretaries and Administrative Assistants, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Outlook Handbook.
  2. Executive Secretaries and Executive Administrative Assistants, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics.
  3. Executive Secretaries and Executive Administrative Assistants, O*NET OnLine.
  4. Business Formation Statistics, U.S. Census Bureau.
  5. Nonfarm Business Sector: Labor Productivity, Federal Reserve Economic Data.
  6. Productivity Statistics, OECD Data Explorer.
  7. World Development Indicators, World Bank DataBank.
  8. ILOSTAT Labour Statistics, International Labour Organization.
  9. 2024 Work Trend Index Annual Report, Microsoft and LinkedIn.
  10. The economic potential of generative AI, McKinsey Global Institute.
  11. Creating helpful, reliable, people first content, Google Search Central.
  12. Search Engine Optimization Starter Guide, Google Search Central.
  13. Dear Manager, You Are Holding Too Many Meetings, Harvard Business Review.
  14. IRS Publication 526, Charitable Contributions.
  15. IRS, Tax Exempt Organization Search.
  16. GAO, Green Book.

Apply the research

Use the finding to frame one question for your own team: which support work is currently invisible, and who should own the next step? A scoped consultation can turn that question into a practical role. Write the question down before the meeting. Name the person who owns the next step.

Turn the finding into a support scope.

Bring the workflow that feels hardest to see. We will help define the role, the evidence it should maintain, and the decisions that stay with leadership.

Talk through the role