Hiring

Executive support role scorecard calibration

A calibration exercise for making an executive support hiring scorecard reflect the real work.

4 min readHireExecutiveTeam editorial
Executive support role scorecard calibration article illustration
Table of contents
  1. Start with the workflows the role will actually own
  2. Use the same scenario and rating anchors across interviewers
  3. After a hiring cycle, compare the scorecard
  4. Related resources
  5. Frequently asked questions

Start with the workflows the role will actually own

Start with the workflows the role will actually own: calendar judgment, meeting preparation, confidential routing, board coordination, or project follow-through. Convert each into observable evidence rather than broad personality traits.

Use the same scenario and rating anchors across interviewers

Use the same scenario and rating anchors across interviewers. Discuss disagreements by returning to the candidate's evidence, not by averaging unstructured impressions or adding a new criterion mid-process.

After a hiring cycle, compare the scorecard

After a hiring cycle, compare the scorecard with the work the role truly requires. Remove criteria that never informed a decision and clarify any dimension that produced inconsistent interpretation.

Frequently asked questions

Should one assistant support the whole executive team?

Sometimes. It works when priorities are clear and executives share one operating rhythm.

What should happen before a consult?

List the meetings, inbox rules, recurring reports, and decisions that need support.

Ready to define the role?

Use a recent leadership week to scope the support that would make the biggest difference. The consultation is a working conversation, not a generic pitch.

Book a consultation